Shop Mobile More Submit  Join Login

Released a .psd of the kARÉ icons to let anyone doing them, and no more kARÉ icons from me... 

49%
101 deviants said Why ? No !!
43%
89 deviants said Yes, finally !!
9%
18 deviants said "That's just being a dick" (actual comment I received :D)

Devious Comments

:iconhaykiii:
Haykiii Featured By Owner Aug 13, 2011
Yes please =)
Reply
:iconseth-del-morro:
seth-del-morro Featured By Owner Dec 15, 2010
hey men .. i really like the Karé icons style .. BUT .. unfortunatly there is only few ones that not cover all what we need .. may be it'll be nice if you release an iconpack .. and because it'll be a bit hard .. i guess a .psd would be great

u may register ur original work under CC license :p
Reply
:icondangzster:
dangzster Featured By Owner Nov 9, 2010  Hobbyist Interface Designer
friend simply going to be honest, do it yourself after all your icons is your job something you created, and finally I admire your work very much to like themes for icons, keep this and not let go of something you created, right? go ahead and make new icons after you are the creator of these wonderful icons! ;)
Reply
:iconnokia1991:
nokia1991 Featured By Owner Nov 4, 2010
only you can make that icon!!
Reply
:icondarkdawg:
darkdawg Featured By Owner Oct 31, 2010
NO, I don't see any reason for you to release the PSD!!
And you yourself told me that if anybody was talented enough to use Photoshop and modify a PSD, than why not make a set on their own or similar to their liking!!!:)
I support you 100% :D and like *emey87 mentioned, kARÉ might just become another copied style of icons!!!
Reply
:icongamorim:
GAmorim Featured By Owner Oct 30, 2010
Release it and keep doing them :D
Reply
:iconclockworklemons:
ClockWorkLemons Featured By Owner Oct 29, 2010  Hobbyist General Artist
it would be good to release them. it gives people the chance to fill out the rest of the apps they have. just say in a readme that by no means may you upload your own ones, so its for personal use only
Reply
:iconmillenniumbugstudios:
millenniumbugstudios Featured By Owner Oct 29, 2010  Professional General Artist
Kare is the most awesome Windows 7 Superbar icon set ever. It was tailored toward the Superbar, and it was darn good at it. AP-Graphik seems to be busy with projects, like every professional. AND like every professional KNOWS, making icons is a process that is time-consuming AND takes a huge deal of creativity. This icon set was unique. It wasn't just any icon set. And as a the originator of this work, AP has the right to stop anyone from copying his work, or publishing mods in any way. AP, continue making them icons! When you're free.
Reply
:iconrose-76:
Rose-76 Featured By Owner Oct 29, 2010
No
I like Your kARE icon . and I wanted to see more Kare icons from you :)
Reply
:iconizzuthug:
IzzuThug Featured By Owner Oct 28, 2010
If you feel that the name for the icons has been shattered and misrepresented then I would stop making them and don't release the psd. But by all means please don't stop if you don't want to, there are awesome icons and would be sorely missed. The community may need these icons but you should truly do what your heart tells you, you don't want a bad taste left in your mouth over this.
Reply
:iconhelkin86:
helkin86 Featured By Owner Oct 28, 2010
Salut, je suis un peu surpris de cette conversation! Je tiens tout d'abord à dire que j'aime beaucoup ton travail et que j'utilise actuellement tes sets d'icônes "kARE" ainsi que "Soft7". Je trouve ça clean et très cohérent!
Mais bien sur j'utilise d'autres programmes que les tiens et pour garder cette cohérence sur mon bureau je "crée" mes icônes "kARE" dans le même style que les tiens (je ne me permet pas de les publier bien sur). Je pense que pas mal de gens son dans mon cas et leur apporter un .PSD permettrait d'élargir tes sets d'icônes pour les programmes de chacun.

Je comprends aussi que tu ne veuilles pas que l'on "touche à ton travail", et je respecte, mais alors pourquoi le publier et le mettre en download.... ? une capture d'écran avec un gros copyright au milieu aurait suffit dans ce cas.

PS: l'intonation est parfois délicate à interpréter quand il s'agit de message écrit mais c'est avec grand respect pour ton travail que je laisse ce post ;)
Reply
:iconfg123:
fg123 Featured By Owner Oct 28, 2010  Student Filmographer
Well, I would prefer if you made a tutorial, instead of releasing a psd. :/ Or just keep making icons, and take 1 request per week or something. :3
Reply
:iconot4ku:
Ot4Ku Featured By Owner Oct 28, 2010  Professional Artist
Ne fais pas ça, faut que ce soit toi et toi uniquement qui fasse ces icônes, sinon je le dis haut et clair, c'est de la merde.
Tes icônes sont énormes, mais le fait que ce soit toi qui les ait tous fait permet de garder une cohérence, un truc à ne pas perdre pour que ça aie toujours l'air joli ;)

Bref, gardes ton .psd.
Reply
:icongeo17:
Geo17 Featured By Owner Oct 28, 2010
What ever you do,DON'T release the .psd.
Just don't.Listen to what these guys have to say.Do you REALLY think releasing the project will be a good idea?
Reply
:iconnotnobody21:
NotNobody21 Featured By Owner Oct 28, 2010
Please don't listen to the fools asking you to NOT (?!?!) release a PSD. When I theme my taskbar with icons, I need every single one of them to match. This is why I have only been able to use Token icons up to this point, but I would switch to Kare if I was able to make my own for the programs you didn't.
Reply
:iconwarulez:
warulez Featured By Owner Oct 28, 2010
you shouldn't release a psd, it is your work, and shouldn't be copied in order to release a half assed copy
Reply
:iconbgjerlowdesigns:
bgjerlowdesigns Featured By Owner Oct 28, 2010  Professional Interface Designer
I don't you should release a PSD. It's your hard work put into them. But it's up to you
Reply
:iconphs2:
phs2 Featured By Owner Oct 28, 2010  Hobbyist Digital Artist
It's your own work man don't release it. :no:
Reply
:iconemey87:
emey87 Featured By Owner Oct 28, 2010  Hobbyist Interface Designer
I suppose that is something similar like the "token" icons, most copied icon style ever: [link] IMHO he cutted the icon with the magic wand and placed the logo...
Reply
:iconemey87:
emey87 Featured By Owner Oct 28, 2010  Hobbyist Interface Designer
[link]

btw, never release that .psd :)
Reply
:iconap-graphik:
ap-graphik Featured By Owner Oct 28, 2010
I've answered "Why ? No !!" So count one less ^^
Reply
:iconfatezoom:
FateZoom Featured By Owner Oct 28, 2010  Student Interface Designer
dont you dare, release the .psd there might never be a great release!
Reply
:iconte0o:
te0o Featured By Owner Oct 28, 2010
Please, make more of them without giving any .psd. Nobody will can make them like you.
Reply
:icongeo17:
Geo17 Featured By Owner Oct 28, 2010
What happened,dude? :(
Reply
:iconap-graphik:
ap-graphik Featured By Owner Oct 28, 2010
I don't want others to make icons in the kARÉ style (because most don't understand the way it's done) but some disagree with that : [link]
Reply
:icongeo17:
Geo17 Featured By Owner Oct 28, 2010
Hey dude,I totally disagree.
My opinion is that you release the .psd file for the eager-beavers,so they make their own,BUT for their own use.NO publishing.And,you continue your series.
That's my opinion,but you can use yours too.But I really wanted to see more Kare icons from you =P
Reply
:iconap-graphik:
ap-graphik Featured By Owner Oct 28, 2010
I've asked many time to not release custom icons based on the kARÉ series but some still do it... Releasing the psd will only make things worth about that.
I can't forbid the release of custom icons if I release the psd... Some have no idea what respect is, that's all, and it's the same that don't understand the logic behind my icons...
Reply
:icongeo17:
Geo17 Featured By Owner Oct 28, 2010
Yeah,but because of those guys,you don't really have to stop your releases...you should keep releasing them in my opinion.If you keep giving them attention,they will keep doing that.
Reply
Add a Comment: